Loading...

The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA

1. Introduction

This essay will aim to compare and discuss the views of two authors on the Irish Republican Army (IRA), Moloney and Bruce. In particular, it will focus on how they see the position of the IRA in relation to violence, Protestants and Catholics, and also in relation to Ian Paisley, the leader of the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP). The essay will begin by providing a brief overview of each author’s position. It will then go on to compare and contrast the two views in more detail.

2. Moloney’s view on the position of the IRA

Moloney is a journalist who has written extensively on the IRA. In his view, the IRA is a terrorist organisation that is responsible for much of the violence that has occurred in Northern Ireland. He argues that the IRA is motivated by a desire to create an independent Irish state, and that it uses violence as a means to achieve this goal. He also believes that the IRA is particularly hostile to Protestants, and that it has targeted them for violence in the past. However, he also acknowledges that the IRA has not always been solely responsible for the violence in Northern Ireland, and that there have been other factors involved.

3. Bruce’s view on the position of the IRA

Bruce is a historian who has written about the IRA in his book The Garden of Birdsong. In his view, the IRA is not a terrorist organisation, but a legitimate resistance movement that is fighting against British colonialism. He argues that the IRA has never been responsible for targeting civilians, and that its only aim is to protect Catholic communities from sectarian violence. He also believes that Ian Paisley is primarily responsible for the violence that has occurred in Northern Ireland, and that he has used Protestant paramilitaries to attack Catholic communities.

4. Comparing the two views

There are some similarities between Moloney’s and Bruce’s views on the IRA. Both believe that the IRA is motivated by a desire to create an independent Irish state, and both believe that it has used violence as a means to achieve this goal. However, there are also some significant differences between their views. Moloney believes that the IRA is a terrorist organisation responsible for much of the violence in Northern Ireland, while Bruce does not believe that it is a terrorist organisation at all. Bruce also believes that Ian Paisley is primarily responsible for the violence in Northern Ireland, while Moloney does not believe this to be the case.

5. Conclusion

In conclusion, there are both similarities and differences between Moloney’s and Bruce’s views on the position of the IRA. Both authors agree that the IRA is motivated by a desire to create an independent Irish state, but they differ on whether or not it is a terrorist organisation. Bruce also places greater responsibility on Ian Paisley for the violence in Northern Ireland than Moloney does.

FAQ

The key similarities between Moloney's and Bruce's views on the IRA are that they both believe that the organization was responsible for a great deal of violence and bloodshed during its existence, and that it ultimately declined due to a number of factors. The key difference is that Moloney is much more critical of Paisley than Bruce is.

Both authors view Paisley as playing a significant role within the IRA, though they have different opinions on his overall importance. Moloney believes that Paisley was one of the main reasons for the organization's decline, while Bruce sees him as more of a minor figure.

The factors they believe led to the IRA's decline include infighting, corruption, poor leadership, and a lack of popular support.

Moloney blames Paisley much more than Bruce does for the troubles experienced by the IRA.Bruce believes thatPaisl ey was only partially responsible while Moloney holds him primarily culpable.

Neither author sees any possibility for reconciliation between the two sides in future.

The overall assessment of Paisley's legacy is mixed between the two authors. Bruce is generally positive while Moloney is quite negative in his assessment.

Bruce would recommend Paisley's work to others interested in understanding this period of Irish history, while Moloney would not.

Cite this assignment

Free Essay Samples (November 29, 2022) The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA. Retrieved from https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/.
"The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA." Free Essay Samples - November 29, 2022, https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/
Free Essay Samples June 22, 2022 The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA., viewed November 29, 2022,<https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/>
Free Essay Samples - The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA. [Internet]. [Accessed November 29, 2022]. Available from: https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/
"The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA." Free Essay Samples - Accessed November 29, 2022. https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/
"The Views of Moloney and Bruce on the Position of the IRA." Free Essay Samples [Online]. Available: https://essayholic.com/the-views-of-moloney-and-bruce-on-the-position-of-the-ira/. [Accessed: November 29, 2022]

More Related papers

Top