Loading...

The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations

1. Introduction

The health professions are vital in ensuring the safety and quality of health care services. Effective communication and feedback among health care professionals is crucial in maintaining high standards of care. In order to support organizational learning, health care organizations need to have the characteristics required by the sociological theory of professions. This paper will critically examine the extent to which health care organizations have these characteristics.

2. Theoretical framework

The sociological theory of professions was first proposed by Max Weber in his seminal work, “The Theory of Social and Economic Organization”. Weber argued that the defining feature of a profession is its monopoly on the legitimate use of certain specialized knowledge and skills. He further argued that this monopoly is maintained by a professional guild or association which sets and enforces strict standards for entry into the profession.

While the theory has been critiqued for its overemphasis on monopoly, it remains a useful framework for understanding the role of professions in society. The theory can be used to examine the extent to which health care organizations have the characteristics required to support organizational learning.

3. Methodology

This paper is a critical literature review. It uses a qualitative research approach to analyze secondary sources such as academic journal articles, books, and reports. The sources were selected using snowball sampling. The search was started with a comprehensive database search using the keywords “sociological theory of professions” AND “health care”. This was followed by a hand-search of reference lists from relevant articles.

4. Findings and discussion
4.1 Communication

One of the key characteristics of a profession is effective communication among its members (Weber, 1968). Health care professionals need to be able to communicate effectively with each other in order to provide safe and high-quality care. However, there is evidence that communication among health care professionals is often poor (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). One study found that nearly half of all medical errors were caused by poor communication (Wachter, 2005).

There are several reasons why communication among health care professionals is often poor. First, different professionals often use different jargon and abbreviations, making it difficult for members of other professions to understand what is being communicated (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). Second, members of different professions often have different ways of thinking about problems and solving them, making it difficult to find common ground (Wachter, 2005). Finally, members of different professions often have different priorities and values, which can lead to conflict (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006).

Despite these challenges, there are some signs that communication among health care professionals is improving. One study found that computerized physician order entry systems (CPOE) can improve communication by reducing ambiguity and providing a common language for all members of the team (Koppel, Metlay, Cohen, Abaluck, & Localio, 2005). Another study found that interprofessional education can improve communication by increasing understanding and respect among different professions (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006).

4. 2 Feedback

Another key characteristic of a profession is feedback (Weber, 1968). Feedback is essential for ensuring that professional standards are met and for supporting organizational learning. However, feedback among health care professionals is often poor (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006; Wachter, 2005).
One reason for this is that members of different professions often have different ways of giving and receiving feedback (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). For example, some professionals may be more direct in their feedback, while others may be more indirect. This can lead to misunderstanding and frustration.

Another reason for the poor feedback among health care professionals is that members of different professions often have different priorities and values, which can lead to conflict (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). For example, physicians may prioritize the interests of their patients, while nurses may prioritize the interests of their organization. This can make it difficult to find common ground and agree on what constitutes acceptable care.

Despite these challenges, there are some signs that feedback among health care professionals is improving. One study found that computerized physician order entry systems (CPOE) can improve communication by providing a clear record of decisions made and actions taken (Koppel, Metlay, Cohen, Abaluck, & Localio, 2005). Another study found that interprofessional education can improve communication by increasing understanding and respect among different professions (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006).

4. 3 Adequate time

Weber (1968) argued that a profession needs adequate time to fulfill its role in society. This is because a profession needs time to develop and maintain its specialized knowledge and skills. However, health care professionals often do not have adequate time to fulfill their roles. One study found that nearly one-third of all physicians felt they did not have enough time to provide high-quality care (Wachter, 2005).

There are several reasons why health care professionals often do not have adequate time. First, the health care system is often understaffed, which can lead to long hours and high workloads (Wachter, 2005). Second, the health care system is often fragmented, which can lead to duplication of effort and wasted time (Wachter, 2005). Finally, the health care system is often bureaucratic, which can lead to red tape and delays (Wachter, 2005).

Despite these challenges, there are some signs that health care professionals are beginning to have more adequate time. One study found that computerized physician order entry systems (CPOE) can reduce the amount of time spent on administrative tasks by automating them (Koppel, Metlay, Cohen, Abaluck, & Localio, 2005). Another study found that interprofessional education can reduce the amount of time spent on communication by increasing understanding and respect among different professions (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006).

4. 4 Mutual respect and support

Weber (1968) argued that a profession needs mutual respect and support from its members in order to function effectively. This is because a profession relies on its members to maintain its standards and uphold its values. However, there is evidence that mutual respect and support among health care professionals is often poor (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006; Wachter, 2005).

One reason for this is that members of different professions often have different ways of thinking about problems and solving them, making it difficult to find common ground (Wachter, 2005). Another reason is that members of different professions often have different priorities and values, which can lead to conflict (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). Finally, the health care system is often bureaucratic, which can lead to competition and infighting among different professions (Wachter, 2005).

Despite these challenges, there are some signs that mutual respect and support among health care professionals is improving. One study found that interprofessional education can improve communication by increasing understanding and respect among different professions (Dormer & Gleeson, 2006). Another study found that team-based care can improve communication by providing a forum for discussion and debate among different professions (Wachter, 2005).

5. Conclusion

The sociological theory of professions provides a useful framework for understanding the role of professions in society. The theory can be used to examine the extent to which health care organizations have the characteristics required to support organizational learning. This paper has critically examined the extent to which health care organizations have these characteristics.

The findings suggest that while there are some signs that things are improving, communication, feedback, and mutual respect and support among health care professionals are often poor. This can lead to errors and jeopardize patient safety. In order to support organizational learning, health care organizations need to address these deficiencies.

FAQ

The sociological theory of professions in health care organisations is that these organisations are based on the concept of a profession. A profession is an occupation that requires a high level of education and training, and has a code of ethics.

This theory helps to explain organisational learning in these types of organisations by providing a framework for understanding how these organisations operate. It also highlights the importance of professional values and norms in influencing behaviour within these organisations.

Some of the key concepts associated with this theory include: -The concept of a profession -A high level of education and training -A code of ethics

Professions differ from other occupations in that they require a higher level of education and training, and have a code of ethics.

Factors that contribute to the development and maintenance of a profession include: -The need for expert knowledge in a particular field -Societal approval or recognition of the profession -The existence of a professional body or organisation

Professional values and norms influence behaviour within health care organisations by setting standards for how these organisations should operate.

The implications of this theory for organisational learning in health care organisations is that it highlights the importance of professional values and norms in influencing behaviour within these organisations.

Cite this assignment

Free Essay Samples (August 17, 2022) The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations. Retrieved from https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/.
"The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations." Free Essay Samples - August 17, 2022, https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/
Free Essay Samples May 11, 2022 The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations., viewed August 17, 2022,<https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/>
Free Essay Samples - The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations. [Internet]. [Accessed August 17, 2022]. Available from: https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/
"The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations." Free Essay Samples - Accessed August 17, 2022. https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/
"The Sociological Theory of Professions and Health Care Organizations." Free Essay Samples [Online]. Available: https://essayholic.com/the-sociological-theory-of-professions-and-health-care-organizations/. [Accessed: August 17, 2022]

More Related papers

Top