Loading...

The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing

1. Introduction

The prohibition of alcohol in the United States lasted for about thirteen years, from 1920 to 1933. It was a time during which the production, transport, sale, and consumption of alcohol were banned by the Eighteenth Amendment to the Constitution.

The Prohibition era was a controversial time in American history. There were those who strongly supported the ban on alcohol, believing that it would lead to a decrease in crime and immoral behavior. On the other hand, there were those who opposed Prohibition, arguing that it was ineffective and caused more problems than it solved.

In this essay, we will take a look at the arguments made by two people who wrote about Prohibition – John Gordon Cooper, who believed that it was a success, and William H. Stayton, who believed that it was a failure. We will then compare and contrast their arguments to see which side is more convincing.

2. The arguments by John Gordon Cooper (1872-1955), “Prohibition is a success” (1924)

In his article “Prohibition is a success”, John Gordon Cooper makes the following arguments in support of Prohibition:

– There has been a decrease in crime since Prohibition began. This is because people are not as likely to commit crimes when they are sober.
– There has been a decrease in the consumption of illegal liquor. This is because people are more aware of the dangers of alcohol and are less likely to drink it.
– There has been an increase in the number of people who are employed in the legal alcohol industry. This is because there is more demand for legal alcohol now that it is illegal.
– There has been an increase in tax revenue since Prohibition began. This is because the government is able to collect taxes on the sale of legal alcohol.
– There has been a decrease in the number of accidents and deaths caused by alcohol. This is because people are less likely to drink and drive when alcohol is illegal.

3. The arguments by William H. Stayton (1861-1942), “Prohibition is a Failure” (1926)

In his article “Prohibition is a Failure”, William H Stayton makes the following arguments against Prohibition:
– Prohibition has not been effective in reducing the consumption of illegal liquor. This is because people are still able to obtain alcohol through bootlegging and speakeasies.
– Prohibition has led to corruption among law enforcement officials. This is because they are able to collect bribes from those who are selling illegal liquor.
– Prohibition has resulted in an increase in crime. This is because people are willing to break the law in order to obtain alcohol.
– Prohibition has caused a decline in tax revenue. This is because the government is not able to collect taxes on the sale of illegal liquor.
– Prohibition has led to an increase in accidents and deaths caused by alcohol. This is because people are drinking more moonshine, which is often distilled incorrectly and can be poisonous.
4. A comparative analysis of the two articles After looking at both articles, it seems that Stayton’s arguments against prohibition are more convincing than Cooper’s arguments for prohibition. Here’s why: – Stayton’s arguments are based on facts and data, while Cooper’s arguments are mostly based on opinion. – Stayton’s arguments are more current, as they are based on data from 1926. Cooper’s arguments are from 1924, which means that they predate Prohibition. – Stayton’s arguments take into account the negative aspects of Prohibition, while Cooper’s arguments only focus on the positive aspects.

5. Conclusion In conclusion, it seems that William H. Stayton’s arguments against Prohibition are more convincing than John Gordon Cooper’s arguments for Prohibition. This is because Stayton’s arguments are based on facts and data, while Cooper’s arguments are mostly based on opinion.

FAQ

The main goals of prohibition were to reduce crime and corruption, improve public health, and reduce the social problems associated with alcohol abuse.

Prohibition had a significant impact on society and individuals. It led to a decrease in crime rates, an increase in public health, and a reduction in the social problems associated with alcohol abuse.

Prohibition was effective in achieving its goals.

Some of the unintended consequences of prohibition were an increase in organized crime, an increase in illegal alcohol production and consumption, and a decrease in tax revenue from legal alcohol sales.

The lessons that can be learned from Prohibition about alcohol regulation today are that prohibition is not an effective way to reduce crime or improve public health, and that it can have negative unintended consequences.

Cite this assignment

Free Essay Samples (October 4, 2022) The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing. Retrieved from https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/.
"The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing." Free Essay Samples - October 4, 2022, https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/
Free Essay Samples March 3, 2022 The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing., viewed October 4, 2022,<https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/>
Free Essay Samples - The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing. [Internet]. [Accessed October 4, 2022]. Available from: https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/
"The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing." Free Essay Samples - Accessed October 4, 2022. https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/
"The Failure of Prohibition: Why William H. Stayton’s Arguments are More Convincing." Free Essay Samples [Online]. Available: https://essayholic.com/the-failure-of-prohibition-why-william-h-staytons-arguments-are-more-convincing/. [Accessed: October 4, 2022]

More Related papers

Top