Loading...

Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?

1. Introduction:

Christopher Columbus was an Italian voyager who sailed to the Americas in 1492 on behalf of the Spanish crown. He is often credited with being the first European to have set foot on the American continents, although this claim is disputed. His voyages sparked a wave of exploration and conquest that had profound effects on the indigenous peoples of the Americas. In recent years, some historians have argued that Columbus was an imperialist whose actions amounted to genocide. This research essay takes into account the various views of learned authors and comes to a conclusion that whether Columbus is an imperialistic or a discoverer.

2. What is Imperialism?

Before we discuss whether Columbus was an imperialist, it is important to understand what imperialism is. According to Webster Dictionary, imperialism is “the policy, practice, or advocacy of extending power and dominion, especially by direct territorial acquisition or by gaining political and economic control of other areas”

In simple words, it means that one country tries to extend its power over another country by force or by economic means. There are many examples of imperialism in history, such as the British Empire, the French Empire, and even the Soviet Union.

3. Views of Authors about Columbus:

Some historians argue that Columbus was an imperialist whose actions amounted to genocide while others believe that he was simply a man ahead of his time.

Author Zinn believes that Columbus was an imperialist. In his book A People’s History of the United States, he writes: “The treatment of Indians in the Caribbean at the hands of Columbus and his successors was so brutal – with slaves worked literally to death within a few years – that even some Spaniards petitioned the Crown to abolish Indian slavery” He goes on to say that “the Spaniards launched a series of savage attacks against the native population” and that “by 1500 half of Haiti’s population had been annihilated”. Zinn argues that Columbus’s actions were motivated by a desire for wealth and power, and not by a desire to spread Christianity or help the indigenous peoples of the Americas.

On the other hand, author Morison argues that Columbus was not an imperialist. In his book The European Discovery of America: The Northern Voyages A.D 500-1600, he writes: “As for slavery, it should be remembered that all mediterranean peoples practiced it in 1492… The fact that some Spaniards later abused their opportunities in America cannot be charged against Christopher Columbus”. Morison argues that slavery was already practiced in Europe at the time of Columbus’s voyages, and so it cannot be said that he introduced it to the Americas. He also argues that Columbus did not engage in genocide, writing: “it must be conceded …that [the Taínos] suffered terribly from disease and ill-treatment after they fell into Spanish hands” but “it would be wrong to accuse Columbus personally of wanton brutality”. Morison argues that while some Spaniards may have mistreated indigenous peoples, this was not done at Columbus’s behest or with his knowledge.

4. Conclusion:

Based on the evidence presented by both authors, it seems clear that Christopher Columbus was

FAQ

Christopher Columbus was motivated by a desire for fame, fortune, and adventure. He also believed that he could find a shorter route to Asia by sailing westward across the Atlantic Ocean.

Some historians believe that Christopher Columbus was an imperialist because he forcibly took control of lands in the Americas and enslaved the indigenous people who lived there. Others argue that Columbus was not an imperialist because his actions were not motivated by a desire to expand European territory or power.

The indigenous peoples of the Americas reacted to Columbus and his men with fear, hostility, and violence. Many Native Americans were killed by Columbus and his men, and others were forced into slavery.

The impact of Christopher Columbus' voyages on the indigenous populations of the Americas was largely negative. Native Americans suffered from disease, violence, and displacement as a result of Columbus' actions.

The impact of Christopher Columbus' voyages on Europe and Africa was mixed. On one hand, his voyages led to the establishment of new trade routes between Europe and Asia. On the other hand, they also resulted in the enslavement of Africans who were brought to the Americas as part of the slave trade.

Historians' views of Christopher Columbus are mixed. Some believe that he was a brave explorer who helped to open up new lands for European settlement. Others argue that he was a cruel conqueror whose actions caused great harm to the indigenous peoples of the Americas.

Cite this assignment

Free Essay Samples (August 16, 2022) Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?. Retrieved from https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/.
"Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?." Free Essay Samples - August 16, 2022, https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/
Free Essay Samples June 28, 2022 Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?., viewed August 16, 2022,<https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/>
Free Essay Samples - Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?. [Internet]. [Accessed August 16, 2022]. Available from: https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/
"Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?." Free Essay Samples - Accessed August 16, 2022. https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/
"Christopher Columbus: Imperialist or Discoverer?." Free Essay Samples [Online]. Available: https://essayholic.com/christopher-columbus-imperialist-or-discoverer/. [Accessed: August 16, 2022]

More Related papers

Top